Through tremendous sacrifices socialist China has brought the coronavirus under control – the number of new daily cases being reduced from the peak of 3,887 on 5 February to 8 on 13 March, a decline of 99.8%. In doing so the Chinese authorities performed an enormous service not only to the Chinese people but also gave a crucial opportunity to the whole rest of the world to prepare.

To precise, through the determined fight against the virus, the China bought almost two months warning to the rest of the world before the coronavirus began to significantly spread there. But the terrible truth is that while China benefitted greatly from determined action against the virus the facts show the West entirely wasted this precious time.

Because the huge economic effect of the coronavirus cannot be separated from its medical impact it is necessary to study the two together. This is due to the fact that the coronavirus is simultaneously a supply and demand side economic shock. The supply side shock is that the health risk means the work force cannot produce normally, causing huge falls in output. The demand side effect is that significant numbers of services and goods, if they are not consumed in the short term, will not be purchased at all – particularly in the service sector. The falls in China’s  Industrial production of 13.5% in January-February, the fall of 20.5% in retail sales and the 25.5% fall in fixed asset investment reflected this impact within China.

The facts show clearly that the spread of the virus in the West is now already reaching levels far higher than at the worst point of the crisis in China. As will be demonstrated, nothing short of a disaster is now unfolding in Europe. The situation in the US, so far, is following Europe with a delay of about 10 days.

This fact that the intensity of the coronavirus crisis in Europe is already worse than at the worst period of the virus in China is concealed by misleading comparisons of the absolute number of cases in Europe compared to China. But, for example, China’s population is 17 times larger than Germany or 23 times larger than Italy. To realistically measure the relative impact of the coronavirus crisis in Europe compared to China it is necessary to measure the virus’s spread in proportion to population.

The peak day for the number of new virus infections in China was 5 February at 3,887. But according to the World Health Organization’s daily situation reports, at the time of writing the peak day in France (780 on March 13) was equivalent to over 16,000 relative to China’s population, in Spain (1,266 on March 13) over 38,000, and in Italy (2,651 on March 12) over 60,000. In France and Spain the relative impact of the virus is therefore more than four times as large as China, in Italy more than 13 times as severe.

Western governments are openly telling their populations that it is only a matter of time before the number of deaths becomes very high. British Prime Minister Johnson announced: ‘many more families, are going to lose loved ones before their time.’ Italy’s cumulative death toll Italy’s cumulative death toll (1400 as of March 14) would be equivalent to around 33,000 in a country with China’s population!

This data makes clear Europe’s situation is already far worse that at the worst period in China. In short, the European governments totally failed to use the time they had to prepare for the virus to arrive.

The virus’s huge economic impact in the West follows from this medical disaster. Data on the impact on production of the virus in the West is not yet available. But the Western economies were already weakening when the coronavirus hit. The peak of the current US and EU business cycles was in the second quarter of 2018. From then until the 4th quarter of 2018 US GDP growth had fallen from 3.2% to 2.3%, and the EU’s from 2.5% to 1.2%. Without an extraordinary stroke of luck the virus hitting already slowing Western economies will push them into recession despite the emergency new measures taken by the Federal Reserve.

As Western companies had already accumulated very large debts any resulting revenue slowdown, creating difficulty to repay this debt, carries a risk of transmission of crisis into credit and other markets.

This explains the literally unprecedented impact on Western share markets. The fall of the US share prices into a bear market, a 20% fall, took only 16 days –  even more rapid than in 1929.

Why, when China has been getting the virus under control, has there been such a catastrophic failure in the West? The reason is in large part because instead of learning the positive lessons of China’s ability to control the virus the Western media and the US government engaged in anti-China propaganda. The bitter truth is that people in the West now face a medical, human and economic disaster due in significant part to this anti-China propaganda.

2 Comments

  1. Dr. George W. Oprisko on March 18, 2020 at 1:18 pm

    This is most certainly true. The CPC sacked provincial/city authorities in Hubei/Whuhan for their failure to act instead of hosting a 40,000 person banquet. They sent teams to Hubei/Whuhan to assess the situation and implemented mitigation procedures immediately. They intervened again when the second administration became obsessed with dotting i(s) and crossing t (s), replacing same with a mission oriented team who got the job done.
    PRC virologists have published studies in peer reviewed journals such as NEJM and JAMA which showed ~ 50% of all cases were asymptomatic. These have been buried while a UK epidemiological study using 3rd hand data that claimed ~>80% to be asymptomatic has received wide attention in the western press / blogs. That for the purpose of obfuscating the mortality of the infection, and to justify doing nothing.
    Thank you for your efforts to inform the world of the advances of China

    INDY

  2. Philippe Gendrault on March 18, 2020 at 5:36 pm

    Absolutely! The late response of European Countries and the United States reeks of the colonial, racist and xenophobe mentality. If one could have imagined some world solidarity in the face of this pandemic, the United States has made sure, as usual, that such cooperation would not happen in persisting its anti-China propaganda,; a propaganda that is becoming simply primitive as illustrated by the absurd labelling of the virus as a “Chinese Virus.”
    But beyond China, this crisis will, unfortunately for many people, reveal the structural and inherent ills of capitalism (among others,the clear lack of public infrastructures) and the inability of the private sector to handle the magnitude of this contagion. The West is going to need all the help it can get, even though it certainly has shown, as usual, no disposition, no grace to possibly deserve it…

Leave a Comment